tumblr boycott day.ronenv-post:Is tumblr really holding a...



tumblr boycott day.

ronenv-post:

Is tumblr really holding a users personal account hostage to extort him into shutting down his service / competing UI? I cannot believe this.

For those of you who dont know, missing e is a great browser extension for tumblr. Its a browser add-on for firefox/chrome/safari with an updated user interface that makes doing some things on tumblr easier. (ie, I can edit posts on my blogs from the permalink page, set reblogs to default to my reblog instead of my main/art blog, etc). Some features (such as keeping tags on reblogs) have even been adopted as real tumblr features.

Then tumblr calledJeremy Cutler, the creator of missing e and asked him to stop distributing it, because they said it was violating the API agreement, hurting their business structure (by allowing users to hide the radar/ads) and page-scraping which put a big load on their servers.

So he took missing-e down, and fixed all of those problems. Missing-e no longer hides the radar, no longer scrapes pages, and no longer uses the API at all. In fact, it doesnt even interact with tumblr everything it does happens once tumblr is already loaded in your browser, between your browser and you.

But apparently that wasnt good enough. Because the page-scraping and API reasons werent tumblrs real/only reasons they didnt like the UI changes missing-e implemented.

Heres where things got interesting:

missing-e:

Moments ago, I participated in surprise conference call with Tumblr staff members. They have indicated to me that they continue t o take issue withMissing eeven with the removal of usage of the Tumblr API. Thats their prerogative, Im sure.

Whether or not I have grounds to justly disagree with them on this, the fact remains that under theTumblr Terms of Service, they are well within their rights to delete my Tumblr blogs as a punitive action should I continue to distribute the extension. They have informed me that this is the course of action they will take should I not acquiesce to their demands.

So, tumblr is threatening to delete his PERSONAL BLOG if he doesnt meet their (unrelated to his personal blog) demands?

Tumblr staff I know you and youre all smart, good people is there a word for when you cant get someone to do what you want, so you threaten to damage them personally in an unrelated way?

Are you really holding users accounts hostage because you dont like the things that the things they build are popular with your users?

extortion/ikstrSHn/

Noun:The practice of obtaining something through threats.

If you want to bring a cease-and-desist against missing-e, thats your right. (And I suppose if you had a case, thats what you would do.) But instead youre threatening to delete a users personal account unless they remove a BROWSER add-on that doesnt interact with your service and that thousands of your users love, because you dont like its features?

Lots of people make lots of browser extensions for lots of sites, from youtube to facebook to everything else. The problem here seems to be that Jeremys extension is very popular. Wouldnt the correct course of action be to, I dont know, hire him?

Now, its true I dont have your side of the story. But thats because tumblr hasnt said anything publicly about this issue.

So please youre all intelligent, good people I would love to hear your side of this.

Because given the positive experiences Ive had with all of you, what Im hearing just doesnt make any sense to me.


Comments